FA Magazine November/December 2026 | Page 44

COVER STORY
Is that discipline or complacency after a long bull market?
“ I think both,” Anspach says. The original 4 % rule was built to survive the worst conditions in market history, she notes,“ and so when you aren’ t experiencing those very worst conditions, to me it does make sense to set a withdrawal rate a bit higher. The research shows if we don’ t do that, the majority of people are just going to have more money at the end of retirement than what they had at the start of retirement.”
The catch is planning for the downside in advance.“ If we are in an AI bubble and that AI bubble pops, what will the adjustments be?” she asks.
Sensible Money skips withdrawal rates altogether, tracking“ fundedness” the way a pension does: the present value of expected withdrawals against current assets.“ We want to see 110 % funded or better in our ratios,” Anspach says. Withdrawals might run 8 % or 9 % in years when a client is delaying Social Security, then drop to 3 % later. When markets fall, the first move is to freeze withdrawals at last year’ s dollar amount.“ I personally have never had to go backwards on a client,” she says.
Choosing the right withdrawal rate also means advisors have to keep an eye on a client’ s longevity. Fifty-two percent of advisors in Financial Advisor’ s retirement survey said they plan for clients to reach age 95, and 26 % plan for a client to reach the age of 100 or older.( This was a new question we asked this year.)
Buckets Beat Brilliance
The survey also asked advisors for the first time how they protect clients from sequence-of-returns risk, and the most popular answer was also the simplest. When allowed to pick up to three tactics, 56 % of those polled chose a bucket or time-segmentation strategy( separating accounts into segments for when the money is needed).
Only 18 % used formal guardrails such as the Guyton-Klinger rules, which adjust the withdrawal amount under certain circumstances, and just 8 % used a bond tent,
Dana Anspach, founder and CEO of Sensible Money, a retirement income planning firm in Scottsdale, Ariz., says newly affluent clients are often startled by how ordinary seven figures can feel.“ I remember growing up, a million dollars was so much money,” she says. People who have more than they ever expected“ might be surprised at how it doesn’ t go as far as they think.” which dramatically increases the allocation to bonds right before and after a retirement date. Other favorites include drawing from taxable or cash accounts first( cited by 39 % of those polled), holding a larger cash reserve( 36 %), using guaranteed income for essential expenses( 35 %) and delaying Social Security( 27 %).
When it comes to bucketing, Anspach says,“ I think it’ s popular because behaviorally people understand it.” Can anyone prove it beats a rebalanced 60 / 40 portfolio?“ No, you can’ t,” she says. But in a bad sequence, clients who can see how many years of spending are protected are“ less likely to make a bad decision and sell out at the wrong time.”
That cushion helps explain why 72 % of advisors now have retirees at 60 % equities or more. Anspach lets equity allocations drift up once clients are past the early“ red zone” and their safe buckets have been refilled.“ We think it should be most conservative at the start of retirement,” she says.“ And then it’ s OK for it to float a little higher, as long as I have a sufficient number of years of cash flow covered.”
The old rule of spending taxable accounts first bothers Anspach more.“ I would hope that’ s actually not the adage anymore,” she says. For clients without pensions, the years between retirement and required minimum distributions are a window for IRA withdrawals and Roth conversions.“ If I can pay taxes at 12 % or 22 % instead of 32 % later, I’ d like to do that.”
Kutner’ s team works down the hall from CPAs( Aprio Wealth Managaement is the
How do you insulate your clients against sequence risk?
Bucket / time-segmentation strategy( cash, bonds, and growth buckets by time horizon)
56.39 %
Dynamic / flexible withdrawal rates with guardrails( e. g., Guyton-Klinger)
17.58 %
Bond tent / glide path( temporarily higher fixed income around the retirement date)
7.99 %
Larger cash reserve to avoid selling equities in a downturn
36.07 %
Guaranteed-income products( annuities, GLWB riders) to cover essential expenses
35.39 %
Delaying Social Security to reduce early portfolio withdrawals
26.71 %
Flexible spending cuts in down years( reducing discretionary withdrawals rather than following a fixed formula)
16.9 %
Strategic account sequencing( drawing from taxable / cash before tax-deferred or equity-heavy accounts)
38.81 %
Other
8.68 %
Based on 438 respondents.
40 | FINANCIAL ADVISOR MAGAZINE | NOVEMBER / DECEMBER 2026 WWW. FA-MAG. COM