COLLEGE PLANNING | ESTATE PLANNING | INSURANCE | INVESTING | PORTFOLIO SPOTLIGHT | REAL ESTATE | RETIREMENT | TAX PLANNING
Custody Was Supposed To Be Boring
The economics of custody have flipped, and Fidelity’ s smallest RIAs are the first to feel the reckoning.
By Jennifer Lea Reed
SMALL RIAS DISCOVERED THE HARD WAY LAST month that the custody business is a lean one characterized by low margins and no glamour. On October 1, Fidelity told existing registered investment advisors that after June 30, 2027, they will need to have at least $ 100 million in managed assets held on its platform, otherwise they will have to move their clients’ assets elsewhere. Fidelity had already set that minimum for new advisors, but now it applies to everyone, new and longtime advisors alike.
A Fidelity spokesperson said the change was made“ for consistency.” Within a week, Betterment was offering to waive its platform fee through 2028 for Fidelity firms that move over.
Tim Welsh, who helped build Schwab’ s custody business for independent advisors a quarter century ago, sums up the job in two sentences.“ It’ s probably the most boring thing in the world, being a custodian,” says Welsh, now president and founder of consulting firm Nexus Strategy.“ Just as long as you don’ t screw it up.”
This fall, custody stopped being boring for small RIAs. The Fidelity news hit during an unprecedented season of change for the custodial landscape. In August, Vanguard had agreed to acquire Altruist, the custodian that built its brand on welcoming small firms with no minimums.
Altruist’ s founder and CEO, Jason Wenk, responded to the Fidelity news on LinkedIn by posting:“ Should be a great first half of 2027 for Altruist! Worth pondering: does it stop here, or start here? Is a $ 250M minimum coming? Do you want to barely meet a minimum?”( The news slipped out in part because one of Fidelity’ s advisors, Alex Chalekian, the founder of Lake Avenue Financial, took to LinkedIn and posted Fidelity’ s letter announcing the new thresholds.)
The largest custodian, Charles Schwab, has made it clear that it is not asking its own small RIAs to leave. Yet it, too, has been making changes that favor large advisors and clients. In August, it said it was raising the minimum for client referrals through its advisor network to $ 5 million.( As recently as a year ago, the minimum was $ 500,000, and was then upped to $ 2 million in January.)
Soon thereafter, the firm announced it would open its own wealth advisory offices, directly competing with the RIAs in the most lucrative cities.“ I don’ t think Fidelity would have made its move unless Schwab had cleared the forest for them with all these negative announcements,” Welsh says.
The anxiety among advisors about Fidelity’ s move soon spread well beyond the Boston custodian giant’ s client list.
Amanda McLean, the director of institutional sales at rival custodian Interactive Brokers, says that since the Fidelity letter went public, her firm has heard from advisors of every size.“ I think they’ re keenly aware that what can happen with Fidelity, and other firms, could happen again. So they’ re preparing,” she says.“ We’ ve been very busy.”
There are several dozen financial services companies already in the custody business, including big players like BNY Mellon’ s Pershing unit, which has been serving RIAs for decades, and Goldman Sachs, which began aggressively seeking RIAs a few years ago. However, these firms, like Fidelity and Schwab, are believed to be interested primarily in serving larger advisors.
Once A Revenue Tsunami, Now A Trickle
Custodians have long given advisors custody for free and made their money on the clients behind them. But after commissions went to zero, trading revenue shrank, and fund revenue-sharing has faded as advisors move clients into low-cost exchange-traded funds.
NOVEMBER / DECEMBER 2026 | FINANCIAL ADVISOR MAGAZINE | 45