FA Magazine November/December 2026 | Page 50

INVESTING
Stephen Caruso, an analyst at Boston researcher Cerulli Associates, thinks of custody as a utility.“ If we were all opening a bakery today, the first person we have to call when we moved into our bakery is the power company,” he says.“ Power companies can’ t work for free.”
And Neither Can Custodians
What’ s left of recompense for these companies, sources say, is cash harvesting, and this is where the reality of custodian economics comes into play. Yes, cash still pays the bills( even as lawsuits and regulators question the rates for sweep accounts— where companies make money on money held overnight). At Schwab, net interest revenue, the spread the firm earns by putting client cash to work, came to nearly $ 3.5 billion of its $ 7.2 billion in third-quarter revenue, according to the company’ s earnings release.
But Welsh estimates that custodians earn roughly 18 basis points a year on client assets, blended from cash sweeps, fund revenue-sharing, order flow and margin lending. Run that through a $ 30,000 account and the custodian collects $ 54 a year. Run it through a $ 30 million account and that account collects a bit more: $ 54,000.
But Caruso doubts cash alone explains Fidelity’ s decision. Sweep income from small firms is“ probably good,” he says,“ but it might not justify the amount of service and support that the group needs.”
Why not simply charge small firms a custody fee? Fidelity’ s own efforts might answer that question: The firm has offered smaller firms a paid way to stay under past minimums, according to Fintrx, a wealth industry data provider. But a fee invites scrutiny of everything else, Welsh explains.“ They don’ t want to unravel it.”
A Small Slice Of A Big Market
Cerulli counts 10,778 RIAs with less than $ 100 million in assets, about 56 % of the market, Caruso says. Only 8 % of those use Fidelity. Yet a whopping 43 % of firms with $ 1 billion or more use it, according to Advizor- Pro’ s 2026“ RIA Custodian Trends” report.
The week after Fidelity’ s letter emerged, Fintrx reviewed its database of Form
ADV filings and found that 986 independent RIAs with less than $ 100 million used Fidelity. A Fidelity spokesperson would only confirm that“ a few hundred firms” were affected and pointed out that most of them used multiple custodians. So while those firms managed $ 151.0 billion in total, Fidelity got only $ 37.2 billion of it.
Couldn’ t those firms simply shift all their assets onto Fidelity’ s platform in order to stay? Even if they wanted to, it’ s unlikely: 706 of those firms, or 72 %, hold less than $ 100 million in total across all their custodial platforms, so moving everything to Fidelity still wouldn’ t allow them to clear the bar. For most of them, Fintrx concluded, the deadline“ is less a question of whether to stay than of where to go.”
The typical firm affected by the change has two employees. The median solo advisor holds $ 11.8 million at Fidelity and $ 27.1 million in total, Fintrx found. To meet the new threshold criterion, that advisory would have to nearly quadruple its assets in nine months.
For another 354 of the firms, Fidelity is already the only custodian they are using, the relationship that is“ almost everything,” Caruso says. Firms that small, he adds, may not even have their own customer relationship management system, and the pain they’ d feel would be acute.
Fidelity May Not Be Done
Caruso says he’ d be surprised to see another big custodian follow Fidelity, since sub- $ 100 million accounts are lucrative at scale. For example, firms with less than $ 100 million on Schwab’ s platform brought in 13 % of its institutional advisor net new assets in the third quarter, and 1,101 firms added Schwab as a custodian on their Form ADVs in 2025, more than three times its closest rival( which happens to be Fidelity; the No. 3 custodian for RIAs is BNY Pershing).
Schwab already holds $ 63.3 billion for Fidelity’ s future refugees, 1.7 times what Fidelity holds. Schwab would be the main alternative for about 70 % of those with a second custodian, according to Fintrx data.
Is Fidelity even finished tinkering with thresholds? Welsh wonders.“ Tomorrow it’ s
$ 250 million. Thursday it’ s $ 500 million,” he says.“ If I have $ 101 million and the market has a bad day, do I have to leave?”
Some firms are already living that math. Fintrx found that 71 firms sit within $ 10 million of the $ 100 million threshold, and one is just $ 300,000 short as of its last Form ADV filing.
The cutoff reaches well past small firms, too, because Fidelity counts only assets on its own platform. Fintrx found 337 affected firms with more than $ 100 million in total AUM. One, in fact, manages $ 4.92 billion but keeps just $ 30.7 million at Fidelity.
Many of the advisors calling Interactive Brokers want a second custodian in place so a future cutoff wouldn’ t require more than“ a flip of a light switch” to counter, McLean says.
From One Custodian To Three?
One challenge to the Fidelity-liberated firms is that smaller platforms don’ t always cover everything a wealth manager needs. An advisor who uses alternatives or bonds alongside stocks and ETFs may end up with a different custodian for each.“ All of a sudden now you have three new account forms in your back office when you used to have one,” Welsh says.
Affected firms realistically have three to six months, not a year, to choose where they’ ll go, given how long it takes to repaper clients and run two systems during a move, Caruso says.
That work lands hardest on the smallest shops. The 354 Fidelity-only firms serve 57,790 client accounts, and more than half of those accounts sit at solo advisors or firms with only one or two employees, according to Fintrx. A solo advisor at one of those firms typically handles 72 accounts alone.
Every one of those accounts will need a new form, and every form gives a client a fresh chance to reconsider the advisor, not just the custodian.“ If I’ ve been asked to move my assets, maybe I’ ve been talking to my buddy down the street at Morgan,” Welsh says, playing the client.“ So why not just give it to him?”
Custody, it turns out, was only boring because nobody had screwed it up.
46 | FINANCIAL ADVISOR MAGAZINE | NOVEMBER / DECEMBER 2026 WWW. FA-MAG. COM